[Message Prev][Message Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Message Index][Thread Index]

Re: is x10.com dead?



> Some people drive Chevys, some Caddys, and a few pay the big bucks for a
> Ferrari.  They all require some level of maintenance to be reliable.  X10
is
> like a Chevy.  If you learn how to drive, it does the job.  If something
> craps out, run down to the local parts store and pick up a replacement for
a
> few bucks.  Not so with the Ferrari.  But the ride is sweet.  And boy,
does
> it give you bragging rights.

I disagree with this analogy on one important factor, reliabilty of
automobiles is backed by sound engineering and decades of regulation.
Neither exists in X-10.  It's crappy engineering, a marvel of cheap shit
being pushed well beyond it's means.  I'm not sure the auto analogy can even
be applied to it, as cars are considerably more complex and influenced by
all manner of different variables.

I don't want bragging rights, I just want something that works reliably
without having to jump through a myriad of geek hoops.  X-10 has not and
fundamentally can not provide that.



comp.home.automation Main Index | comp.home.automation Thread Index | comp.home.automation Home | Archives Home