Re: Which new controller should I choose? Ocelot or LynX10 possibly?

[nobody@xxxxxxxxxxxx (Dave Houston)]

There really is no comparison.

The LynX10 PLC is brain dead, having no memory for storing macros and
timers, so you will need a PC running 24/7 and everything will depend on the
software running on the PC. There are several software applications that
support the LynX10 PLC.

The Ocelot has internal memory and can run stand-alone, under PC supervision
or a combination of its user created internal program and PC supervision.
There is also plenty of software that supports the Ocelot. The Ocelot is
expandable by adding Adnet (RS485) modules.

"monahmat@xxxxxxxxx" <monahmat@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:

>I am wondering what everyones opinions are for HA controllers.  I
>recently purchased a new home and would like to invest in a better
>controller.  I am considering the Ocelot and the LynX10 PLC.  I am
>looking to spend between 100 and 200 dollars.  Good software is also
>important, so if anyone has any suggestions there they would also be
>appreciated.
>
>I began with x10 and the CM11A controller.  I have lots of X10 modules
>that if possible I would like to continue to use for cost saving
>purposes.  I was very unimpressed with the PC interaction with the
>CM11A and pretty much limited myself to using a remote and very simple
>Macros.  I know plan on developing a much more detailed system to
>include lighting, HVAC, video surveilance, house wide audio, and home
>theater components.  If anyone has any suggestions to help me on my
>endeavor they would be greatly appreciated.  All of your previous post
>have been very helpful thus far.
>
>Thanks.
>
>Matt